Shop Our Best-Selling Salt Water Taffy Flavors

One thing we’ve learned after decades in the candy business? Everyone has their own favorite flavors. That’s why we make 80+ true-to-life Taffy Town flavors so you can discover your own! After all, trying the many flavors (some classic, some unique) is part of the fun of enjoying taffy! 

But we’re the first to admit that some of our saltwater taffy flavors do rise above the rest regarding customer popularity. There are some universally loved flavors we had to put on our best-sellers list. Above, shop the best salt water taffy flavors and assortments, as picked by our customers — and see if your own personal favorite made the list!

Flavors of Salt Water Taffy You Can’t Get Enough Of

Our current taffy best-sellers include both old-time classics and modern, inventive flavors; there’s truly something for everyone in our best-sellers collection. Here are just a few of the best taffy flavors according to you!

Peppermint Taffy 

Smooth, fresh, and perfect for the holidays, our peppermint taffy is a perfect after-dinner treat that mixes the unmistakable flavor of peppermint with a sweet, smooth nougat candy.

Vanilla Taffy 

Our vanilla taffy is anything but boring. This traditional taffy flavor gets a gourmet twist thanks to our special, homemade recipe that sets Taffy Town taffy apart from the competition. 

Banana Taffy

Tropical, sweet, and mellow, banana taffy is a favorite among kids and adults alike.

Cotton Candy Taffy

This cotton candy taffy flavor is like unwrapping a piece of nostalgia. You’ll be transported back to the county fair with true-to-life cotton candy flavor in every bit.

Buttered Popcorn Taffy

If you love a good salty-sweet combination, buttered popcorn taffy is for you. With our bite-sized taffy pieces, you can skip the kernels but never the flavor of freshly popped popcorn. 

Watermelon Taffy 

Summer days call for fresh-cut watermelon! Or, the next best thing: our life-like watermelon-flavored taffy that’s just the right amount of sweet and always in season.

Cinnamon Taffy

Add a little spice to your sweet treat with warm cinnamon flavor wrapped in our delicious world’s best taffy nougat. Cinnamon taffy is a classic that never goes out of style.

Black Licorice Swirl Taffy

A wildcard flavor, black licorice taffy is own everyone should try at least once. For those who love it, black licorice is a completely distinct flavor that only gets better thanks to our soft and pillowy taffy consistency.

Chocolate Taffy

Vanilla taffy’s partner in crime, our chocolate taffy is full of rich, chocolatey flavor (but won’t melt in your hand).

Throughout the year, we’re constantly restocking the salt water taffy flavors listed above. If you haven’t tried some of the flavors on the list, what are you waiting for? Now that you know how popular they are, it’s worth a taste test of your own to decide if you could discover a new personal favorite. What’s the best taffy flavor of all? That’s for you to decide.

Can’t Pick Just One? - Try Our Salt Water Taffy Assortments

We get it; choosing just one flavor can be too difficult. That’s why we created our Taffy Town assortments. We combine multiple flavors in one bag or box, so you can pick and choose your piece depending on your mood; plus, there’s something for everyone! If you’re hosting a get-together, giving a gift, or stocking your dessert table for the holidays, assortments are a no-fail solution that gives everyone something to enjoy.

Here are our top-selling salt water taffy assortments: 

• Assorted Taffy Flavors
• Try All Taffy Sampler
• Tropical Taffy Mix
• Sugar-Free Assorted Taffy
• Simply Taffy Mix
• Sassy Taffy

For the Best Salt Water Taffy, Visit Taffy Town

If you’re going to enjoy gourmet candy, it better be the best, right? So if you’re searching for who makes the best salt water taffy to get your candy fix, look no further than Taffy Town. A family business dedicated to quality, our taffy stands out among the rest thanks to our unique recipe and taffy-making process. 

Unlike other taffy makers who pull their taffy, we whip it. By also adding a soft, whipped meringue to our recipe, our taffy offers a softer and chewier bite than traditional taffy. You get all the taffy taste with no sticky, stuck-in-your-teeth mess.

To make the best salt water taffy flavors, we’re constantly developing out-of-this-world creative concepts that push the status quo. Our new and exciting flavor ideas are great additions to the tried and true taffy flavors listed above. So whether you’re looking for an old favorite or want to try something new, the best salt water taffy to order online is only at Taffy Town.